How to Conduct an Effective Klaviyo List Clean-up: A Step-by-Step Guide
Klaviyo’s pricing updates taking effect on 18 February 2025 have created a pressing need for businesses to optimise their marketing spend.

The price updates include billing for both active and suppressed profiles. While the pricing hike may seem daunting, it offers a valuable opportunity to streamline list management and improve email performance by focusing on delivering value to engaged subscribers.
Why Clean Email Lists Matter
A clean email list directly impacts your return on investment (ROI) and ensures your campaigns drive maximum value. Retaining inactive subscribers doesn’t just inflate your Klaviyo costs—it skews performance metrics and damages your sender's reputation. According to Klaviyo, a well-maintained list results in:
- Higher engagement rates
- Better deliverability
- Improved conversion rates
By proactively managing your lists, you’ll position your email marketing efforts for long-term success.
The Opportunity Behind Klaviyo’s Pricing Updates
Instead of viewing Klaviyo’s pricing changes as a challenge, think of them as an opportunity to refine your strategy and improve overall marketing efficiency. Here’s how:
- Better Deliverability: Regular list cleaning ensures your emails reach the inboxes of engaged subscribers.
- Smarter Engagement Tactics: Leverage automation to quickly identify unengaged contacts and suppress them.
- Cross-Channel Targeting: Use suppressed profiles to build behaviour-based retargeting campaigns, such as ads or direct mail, to engage inactive contacts.
Key Metrics to Identify When It's Time for a Clean-Up
Monitoring the following metrics will help you determine when your list needs attention:
- Open rates consistently below 15%
- Click-through rates under 2%
- Bounce rates exceeding 2%
- Spam complaints surpassing 0.1%
- Subscribers inactive for 90+ days
If your numbers fall within these ranges, it’s time to take action.

Step-by-Step: Cleaning Your Klaviyo List
1. Create Smart Segments for Unengaged Contacts
Start by using Klaviyo’s segmentation tools to identify inactive profiles. Target groups might include:
- Subscribers who haven’t opened emails in the last 90 days
- Subscribers with no clicks in the last 180 days
- Profiles with zero purchases despite receiving multiple campaigns
- Contacts who haven’t interacted with any content in 6+ months
2. Suppress or Remove Inactive Subscribers
Once you’ve identified unengaged contacts, follow these steps:
- Export unengaged segments: Create a list of inactive profiles.
- Review for VIPs or high-value prospects: Double-check that valuable contacts aren’t accidentally included.
- Create a suppression list in Klaviyo: Suppress inactive profiles to stop sending them emails, reducing your costs while retaining their data for other uses.
- Monitor performance changes: After suppression, keep an eye on your open and click rates to measure the effectiveness of the clean-up.
3. Re-Engage Before Suppression
Before you permanently suppress or remove subscribers, consider re-engagement efforts:
- Personalised win-back campaigns: Tailor messaging to remind subscribers of your brand.
- Exclusive discounts: Offer compelling deals to entice inactive users.
- Preference centre updates: Give users the option to adjust their communication preferences.
- Surveys: Ask inactive subscribers why they disengaged to improve future campaigns.
4. Focus on Behavior-Based Retargeting
Even after suppression, Klaviyo’s data tracking allows you to leverage insights for retargeting campaigns:
- Meta Ads: Target segments based on user behaviour and preferences.
- PostPilot: Send direct mail campaigns to re-engage inactive customers offline.
5. Automate List Maintenance for Long-Term Health
A one-time clean-up isn’t enough—consistently maintaining your list is essential. Implement these best practices to ensure ongoing health:
- Double opt-in for new subscribers: This ensures only genuinely interested contacts join your list.
- Regular data validation: Remove invalid or bounced emails frequently.
- Automated workflows for inactivity: Set up automated flows to suppress inactive profiles after a set period of no engagement.
- Monthly audits: Schedule routine clean-ups to maintain a healthy and engaged list.
By adopting these strategies, you’ll not only minimise costs but also improve your overall email marketing performance. At Matter Design & Digital, we specialise in helping businesses optimise Klaviyo campaigns to achieve measurable results. For additional tips and resources, explore Klaviyo’s Help Centre and community forums, where you’ll find guidance on list management, engagement tactics, and improving account health.